Canadian homebuyers may find that the math on a mortgage falls short of the profit from a portfolio while renting instead.
By Pira Kumarasamy | 18/04/19
We’ve heard it all before – renting is like throwing money into a pit and watching it burn. There’s no greater investment than purchasing a home. Mortgage payments help build equity. A home’s value will grow over time.
Canadians prefer to own their homes, because it gives them the opportunity to build wealth while holding a tangible asset. However, what starts out as a dream could end up costing far more than originally anticipated. A recent RBC poll found that four in 10 Canadians identify or have identified as being “house poor” - a concept that refers to being overextended and spending a large portion of your monthly income on housing related costs.
The alternative to home ownership is renting, for a presumably lower monthly cost, and investing the difference into a well-balanced portfolio. Let’s take a look at both scenarios.
Option A: Purchasing a home
As millennials clamor to get into the market, it’s not unusual to purchase a ‘starter’ home as a way to get in with the intention of selling at a higher price within a few years. This example looks at a home in Toronto that costs $800,000 assuming an interest rate of 3.29% and a 20 per cent down payment ($160,000).
Option B: Investing in a portfolio
In this example, let’s assume that your initial down payment of $160,000 is invested. You pay rent of approximately $2,850 for a two-bedroom condo in the city or a three-bedroom home in the suburbs. Between your mortgage, utilities, property taxes, monthly maintenance your monthly disbursements while owning are $4,382 (table 3) - a difference of $1,532 per month. If you add this additional amount to your portfolio each month, by the end of five years you will end up with $309,522 assuming a conservative 5 per cent rate of return and monthly compounding.
It’s important to note that there are many assumptions in this example, and the numbers will vary based on a number of factors. The key takeaway is that the most profitable option is not always obvious.
Test drive the numbers
Nicole Wells, VP of home equity, RBC, believes it’s best to assess the kind of lifestyle you want to have and test drive the numbers before making this important decision.
“Set a budget and figure out what that lifestyle looks like,” she says. “If you think you can’t save enough to get into a home faster, then look into rental options.”
The costs of owning a home often take new home owners by surprise. Do your research and put your finances through a ‘stress test’ to ensure that you can comfortably take on not only the regular costs associated with your potential home, but the incidental costs that can arise. It’s also important to note that while interest rates might be relatively low today, they likely won’t stay that way forever.
Make an informed decision
Diversification is the safest bet.
When it comes to the cost of real estate and the benefit of investments and diversification, Jonathan Rivard, a financial advisor with Edward Jones recommends looking at a large portfolio like the Canada Pension Plan for a benchmark.
“The Canada Pension Plan would never put 100% of the money into just real estate or just stocks or bonds,” he says. “If you were thinking like a pension fund and how to create and protect wealth, you would diversify and look at all of your options.”
Homes can be wonderful investments that bring years of joy for you and your family, but they can also bring on added stress. Plan carefully and make the purchase if you’re confident that your finances can withstand the real cost of homeownership.